Good murder mystery names are easy to tell apart, fit the period, and suit the tone of your game. Pick the names first, then check that no two sound alike.
Character names that stay distinct
- Give each character a different first initial, so players do not mix them up.
- Vary the number of syllables and the sounds. Avoid having both “Jack” and “Jake” in one cast.
- Use a title and a surname for a formal feel: Colonel, Lady, Lord, Doctor, Madame, Reverend, Professor or Inspector.
- Put the occupation into the name for quick reading, such as “Chef Bernard” or “Nurse Hatchett.”
- Avoid the names of guests, coworkers or real local people.
Period-accurate names
- 1920s US: Dorothy, Helen, Mildred, Frances; Harold, Walter, Raymond, Clarence.
- Victorian British: Ada, Florence, Edith, Beatrice; Albert, Arthur, Edmund, Percival.
- Mob-themed nicknames: “Knuckles,” “Lucky,” “the Butcher.”
- Western nicknames: “Doc,” “Two-Gun,” “Dusty.”
Punny names and when to use them
Punny names suit comic games. Examples include Justin Thyme, Robyn Banks, Miss Millicent Prune and Krystal Ball. A serious period game can be undercut by joke names, so keep the puns mild for mixed groups and skip them for a dark or period-heavy game.
Color surnames like the ones in the classic board game (Mustard, Plum, Peacock, Green, White) are instantly recognizable. A close copy of those names can feel derivative, so pick your own.
Team and table names
- Holmes & Watson.
- The Mori Arties, a pun on Moriarty, Holmes’s criminal rival.
- 1930s Hollywood icons, such as Gable, Garbo, Mae West, or Fred & Ginger, for themed tables.
Event titles
Titles often use puns or alliteration. Common formulas are “Murder at [place],” “Death of a [role],” “[Theme] and Murder,” and “A Deadly [event].” Examples include “Death at the Speakeasy,” “Murder on the Dance Floor” and “A Killer Cocktail Party.” Put the event title, theme and dress code together on the invitation so guests know what to expect.
Names to avoid
- Puns in a serious period game.
- Titles that copy a famous book or game. Titles can be trademarked or tied to a brand.
- Similar-sounding names, which cause confusion more than intrigue.
- Obvious villain names, which can give the game away early.
For choosing roles to go with these names, see murder mystery party character ideas. For setting the premise around them, see murder mystery dinner story ideas.