A murder mystery with multiple endings gives you replay value, or lets the host choose a culprit who suits the guests who turn up. Each ending needs its own solution, clues and timeline, and every version has to be fair. Plan the shared base story first, then add the endings.
Why write more than one ending
- Guests who play again get a different game.
- The host can pick the culprit to fit who is attending, so the game suits the group.
Three ways to choose the ending
- Host’s choice. Write two to four possible culprits. The host picks one before the party and swaps in the matching clue set.
- Random draw. The culprit is drawn by lot at the start, so even the host may not know who it is.
- Player-driven. Players’ choices or votes in the middle of the game decide which ending plays.
Each candidate needs motive, means and opportunity
Every possible culprit needs a motive, means and opportunity in the shared base story. A culprit chosen by a vote at the end is only fair if the clues support every option. Otherwise guests are voting on guesswork.
Universal clues and ending-specific clues
- Split the clues into universal clues, which are the same in every version, and ending-specific clues, which are swapped out for each ending.
- Keep the ending-specific clues few. Two to four per ending is easier to manage. The clue ideas guide helps you choose them.
A timeline for each ending
Write a separate timeline grid for each ending, and check that none of them conflicts with the universal clues. The timeline guide explains the grid method.
Solutions and red herrings for each ending
Each ending needs its own solution and its own set of red herring explanations. The solution and reveal guide covers the structure to use for each one.
Label and hide the swaps
- Label the clue cards with a discreet code, such as A, B or C, so the host can sort them quickly.
- Keep the character booklets from revealing guilt. The only exception is the murderer, who can receive a sealed instruction card.
Playtest every ending
Playtest every ending, not just the one you like best. A version that nobody tested is the one most likely to fall apart on the night. The playtest guide explains the steps for each version.
Common mistakes
- Thinking multiple endings only means multiple confession scripts. The clues must change too.
- Assuming players will not notice a weak alternative. Each ending must be equally fair and solvable.
- Adding more endings than you can test. The work grows fast with each one.
For the base game this builds on, see how to write your own murder mystery dinner party.