Writing Your Own

What are some good clue ideas for a murder mystery?

What are good clue ideas for a murder mystery? Alibi breakers, personal items, motive papers and safe props, plus how many clues a party solution needs.

On this page
  1. Clues that break an alibi
  2. Clues that tie someone to a secret
  3. Personal-item clues
  4. Props you can use safely
  5. How many clues a solution needs
  6. Clues to avoid

Strong murder mystery clues include a timestamped receipt, a torn letter, a lipstick mark on a glass, a ticket stub, a diary page and a witness’s account of an argument. Each clue does one of three jobs: it breaks an alibi, ties a suspect to a secret, or rules someone out. A clue points to the killer only when it is combined with at least one other clue, so plan them as a set.

Clues that break an alibi

  • A receipt with a timestamp that places someone somewhere else.
  • A train, bus or theater ticket stub that places someone elsewhere, or does not.
  • A witness who heard an argument at a specific time, which contradicts the time on someone’s alibi.

Clues that tie someone to a secret

  • A diary page, love letter or blackmail note that reveals a hidden relationship or a grudge.
  • A bank statement, an IOU or a club matchbook that shows debts or where someone has been.
  • A photograph showing two characters together who claim not to know each other.
  • A will or insurance policy naming a beneficiary. An unsigned new will is a strong motive clue.
  • A coded message in a simple cipher, which suits any era.

Personal-item clues

  • A lipstick mark on a glass or napkin that matches one character’s shade.
  • A monogrammed handkerchief, cufflink or earring found at the scene.
  • A muddy footprint or a shoe size that rules suspects in or out.
  • A torn note in two or three pieces, split between players so they must work together to read it.

Props you can use safely

A prop that looks like medicine can add atmosphere, but label it clearly and use an empty container. Print a made-up drug name on the label, and never fill a prop with real medicine or chemicals. Printed cards are usually clearer than elaborate props, so you do not need to build anything complicated.

How many clues a solution needs

Plan three to five key clues that together point only to the culprit. The rest of the clues should either eliminate a suspect or mislead, as the red herring guide explains. Release clues round by round so the evidence builds over the evening. Each red herring needs an innocent explanation that you can give at the reveal.

Build the clues from your timeline, not the other way round. A clue written after the timeline is set often contradicts it. The timeline guide shows how to check each clue against the night’s events.

Clues to avoid

  • A stopped watch at the time of death. It is a cliché, though it can work as a deliberate fake.
  • A single clue that solves the whole game on its own.
  • A clue that depends on information no guest ever receives.

For a hunt-style game where clues are physically hidden, see the scavenger hunt guide.

The complete guide to writing your own

How to Write Your Own Murder Mystery Dinner Party
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →