Writing Your Own

Murder Mystery Dinner Story and Storyline Ideas

Murder mystery dinner story ideas: a premise checklist, reasons to gather, themes like 1920s speakeasies and manor houses, and original storyline sketches.

On this page
  1. What makes a strong premise
  2. Reasons to gather
  3. Theme ideas
  4. Core motives to pick from
  5. Three original storyline sketches
  6. Avoid these pitfalls

A murder mystery dinner story needs three things: a closed circle of guests, a victim several of them wanted dead, and a reason to gather. The setting is the backdrop. The story is who wanted the victim gone, and why.

What makes a strong premise

  • A closed circle. People who cannot easily leave, such as a manor house in a snowstorm or a cruise ship.
  • A victim several guests wanted dead. A disliked victim gives more suspects a motive.
  • A reason to gather that gives every guest a stake in the evening.

Reasons to gather

  • A will reading
  • A birthday or anniversary
  • An engagement or wedding
  • A retirement party
  • A family or school reunion
  • An award dinner
  • A wine tasting
  • A séance
  • A film premiere

Pick the one that puts the victim and every suspect in the same room for a plausible reason.

Theme ideas

  • 1920s speakeasy or Gatsby-style party. Bootleggers, flappers, a jazz singer and a Prohibition agent. This is the most popular theme.
  • Country manor weekend. A lord or lady, a butler, the heir, a family doctor and a solicitor, cut off when a bridge washes out.
  • Hollywood golden age (1930s to 1950s). A fading star, a director, a gossip columnist, a starlet and a studio boss.
  • Mafia wedding or casino night. Rival families, debts and a missing payoff.
  • Cruise ship or train. A fixed passenger list and no way off until the next port or station.
  • Wild West saloon. A land deed, a gold claim, a sheriff, a gambler and a saloon owner.
  • Victorian séance. A medium, a skeptic, a grieving widow and a possible hoax.
  • Ski lodge or mountain cabin. Snowed in, with the power cut.
  • High school reunion. Old grudges, a decades-old secret and a prom king or queen.
  • Holiday themes. A Christmas party, a Halloween masquerade or a New Year’s Eve countdown.

Choose a theme guests can dress for cheaply. That boosts turnout and gets more guests invested in their costumes.

Core motives to pick from

Money or inheritance, love or jealousy, revenge, blackmail, hiding a secret, and ambition. Mix them across the cast so that no two suspects share the same reason to act.

Three original storyline sketches

  • The Last Will at Ashcombe Hall (country manor). At his seventieth birthday dinner, a wealthy widower tells the family he has changed his will. By midnight he is dead in the library, and every guest had a reason to want that new will destroyed.
  • Last Call at the Velvet Room (1920s). A nightclub owner is found dead after the band packs up. Each guest owed the club money, and the ledger that recorded the debts has gone missing.
  • Opening Night at the Silver Arc (Hollywood). A studio’s gala premiere ends with its biggest star found dead in the projection booth. The director, a gossip columnist and a rival starlet each held a secret the star planned to publish.

Each sketch is a starting point. Build the solution first, as the solution and reveal guide explains, then add the clues to match.

Avoid these pitfalls

  • Treating the theme as the story. The theme is the setting. The story is who wanted the victim dead, and why.
  • Copying a famous plot or title. Game and series names can be trademarked, and a close copy of a plot can infringe copyright, so invent your own.
  • Using a real tragedy as the setting. A famous disaster may strike some guests as insensitive.
  • Writing a premise you cannot clue. If a storyline has no clear way to show who did it, rework it before you write the cast. The character guide covers how to turn each storyline into roles.

For the wider process, see how to write your own murder mystery dinner party.

The complete guide to writing your own

How to Write Your Own Murder Mystery Dinner Party
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →