A roaring 20s murder mystery dinner is one of the easiest themes to set up. Prohibition gives the plot a built-in crime, the look is widely recognized, and most guests can pull together a dress or a three-piece suit from their own closet.
Prohibition ran in the United States from January 1920 until its repeal in December 1933. That is why speakeasies, bootleggers and raids are so closely tied to the decade, and why they make such good plot devices.
Set the scene: speakeasy, password and jazz
Speakeasy staples include a door password, a hidden bar and a jazz band. You can use the password as a way to greet arrivals: guests say it at the door before they step in. A recording of Louis Armstrong, Duke Ellington, Bessie Smith or Jelly Roll Morton sets the mood, and the Charleston is a dance you can teach early in the night.
Characters and plot hooks
Useful characters include a bootlegger, a flapper, a jazz singer, a gangster, a Prohibition agent, an heiress, a club owner, a crooked cop and a chorus girl. Give each one a reason to be at the speakeasy and a secret that ties to the crime.
Three plot hooks suit the period well:
- A raided speakeasy, with someone tipping off the agents.
- A poisoned glass of bootleg gin.
- A dispute over a rum-running route.
Drinking itself wasn’t illegal under Prohibition. Making, selling and transporting alcohol were. That’s a useful detail for the plot: the crime is the bootlegging, not the sipping.
Costumes guests can actually wear
For women, the classic look includes a drop-waist dress, beaded or sequined pieces, a cloche hat, T-strap shoes, a long pearl strand and a feathered headband. For men, think three-piece suits, suspenders, bow ties, fedoras, boater or newsboy caps, two-tone shoes and pocket squares.
A few costume notes help guests get the look right:
- Heavy fringe flapper dresses are mostly a modern costume look. Beading and drape are closer to what many 1920s dresses used.
- Hemlines were lower early in the decade and rose to about the knee only around 1925 to 1927. If guests want strict accuracy, they can plan for longer skirts.
- Zoot suits belong to the 1940s, not the 1920s.
- Pinstripe “gangster” suits are a Hollywood convention more than a 1920s fact. They’re fine for a party, but they aren’t strictly period-accurate.
If a full outfit is too much, ask each guest to choose one strong accessory, such as a pearl strand, a fedora or a pocket square.
Drinks and food
Period cocktails include the Bee’s Knees (gin, lemon and honey), the Sidecar, the Gin Rickey, the French 75 and the Southside. Offer mocktails or a “near beer” for guests who don’t drink, so everyone has something to hold during the scene changes.
Period-style dishes include oysters Rockefeller, shrimp cocktail, deviled eggs, Waldorf salad, lobster Newburg and pineapple upside-down cake. Shellfish is a common allergen, so label any shrimp, lobster or oyster dishes clearly.
Music and décor
Dim lighting, vintage glassware and printed clue cards go a long way. The Art Deco look, with black, gold and cream and geometric fans and sunbursts, fits the era well. Build a jazz playlist for the arrival and between rounds, and turn it down during the clue reads so guests can hear each other.
Clue ideas
- A bootlegger’s ledger with a list of deliveries and a missing entry.
- A coded telegram that only makes sense once two guests compare notes.
- A cocktail napkin with a half-written address.
- A pearl necklace with a broken clasp.
Pacing the night
Run the clue rounds between courses. Appetizers can go with round one, the main course with the suspect interviews, and dessert with the final accusation. Keep the mingling short enough that guests don’t lose the thread.
Safety
Feather boas and long scarves catch fire easily near candles. Keep open flames well away from costumes, and use battery candles on the tables. Use obviously toy prop guns if you include any.
Related themes
If your guests enjoy the speakeasy setting, the casino night guide uses similar gambling motives. The mafia guide covers organized-crime roles in more detail. For a wider set of options, see the theme ideas overview.