Drinks help set the theme and keep the room moving. The best options are easy to batch, so the host isn’t bartending during the rounds. Include non-alcoholic choices that feel just as festive, and read the safety notes on alcohol, absinthe, and dry ice before the party.
Themed cocktails for a 1920s night
These classics suit a Prohibition-era theme. Adjust the proportions to taste.
- Corpse Reviver No. 2: equal parts gin, Cointreau, Lillet Blanc, and lemon juice, with an absinthe rinse
- Death in the Afternoon: absinthe topped with chilled Champagne. The drink is often attributed to Hemingway.
- French 75: gin, lemon juice, and sugar syrup, topped with Champagne
- Bee’s Knees: gin, lemon juice, and honey syrup
- Last Word: equal parts gin, green Chartreuse, maraschino liqueur, and lime juice
- Other period drinks: Sidecar, Gin Rickey, Manhattan, and Old Fashioned
Absinthe is strong, so serve small pours. Make sure guests know what is in each drink.
Mocktails
Non-alcoholic drinks can match the theme just as well:
- Shirley Temple
- Sparkling grape juice, labeled as a “poison”
- Virgin mojito
- Cranberry-lime spritzer
Label mocktails clearly, and serve them as nicely as the cocktails. Guests who don’t drink alcohol shouldn’t have to ask what is on offer.
A poison punch and a color trick
A dark red or green punch in a labeled, apothecary-style bottle or punch bowl suits a murder theme. Butterfly pea flower tea makes a good reveal. It turns from blue to purple or pink when citrus is added, because of a change in pH.
Batch drinks for the host
Make a punch or a batch cocktail before guests arrive, so the host isn’t behind the bar during the rounds. Set up a self-serve station with water and non-alcoholic options.
Name drinks for the game
Renaming drinks for characters or clues adds fun. Names such as “Alibi” or “Smoking Gun” tie into the story. Write the names on the menu so guests can connect each drink to the game.
Safety and responsible serving
- One US standard drink contains about 14 grams of pure alcohol. Keep that in mind when you plan quantities.
- Offer plenty of non-alcoholic options and water. Plan rides home or sleeping arrangements before the party.
- Too much alcohol early can make guests miss or forget clues, so pace the drinks through the evening.
Dry ice
Dry ice can add a smoky effect, but it needs care. It is extremely cold, about −78.5°C (−109.3°F).
- Use food-grade dry ice only.
- Never swallow it or handle it with bare hands.
- Don’t seal it in a closed container, because the pressure can burst it.
- Check that no solid pieces remain in a glass before you serve it.
Activated charcoal drinks
Black drinks made with activated charcoal look dramatic, but charcoal can reduce how well some medicines work. If any guest takes regular medication, skip these drinks or check first.
Common misconceptions
- “Activated charcoal drinks are harmless.” They can interfere with some medicines.
- “Dry ice is safe once it stops fizzing.” Check that no solid pieces remain.
- “Mocktails are an afterthought.” Give them the same care as the cocktails.
For food to pair with drinks, see murder mystery menu ideas. For the full hosting plan, see how to host a murder mystery dinner party. For the budget side, see how much it costs to host a murder mystery dinner.