Each murder mystery game sets its own rules, so the kit’s instructions come first. Most games share a core, though: stay in character, read only your own booklet, reveal information only when the round tells you to, and submit a written accusation at the end.
Rules most games share
- Stay in character for the whole game.
- Read only your own booklet. Don’t read ahead to later rounds.
- Don’t show your booklet or clue cards to other guests unless the instructions say to.
- Reveal information only when your round says so.
- Keep your phone put away unless the game uses it.
The host controls the timing
The host usually decides when each round starts and ends, and hands out clues. When the host calls the next round, guests move on, even if the conversation is still going. At the end, the host reads the solution aloud or opens a sealed booklet.
Lying and direct questions
Lying rules vary more than any other rule. In general:
- In some games, only the murderer may lie.
- In others, any guest may lie, except about specific facts.
- Some games require honest answers to direct questions. Others let you deflect.
Check which rule applies before the first round. How to brief your guests explains how to say it out loud, so nobody argues about it mid-game.
Accusations and the reveal
Accusations are usually written privately. Each one names who committed the crime, how it was done, and why. Once submitted, accusations usually can’t be changed. After that, the solution is revealed.
Variants
- Wink murder: The killer “kills” other players by winking at them. Detectives try to catch them in the act. It appears with other parlor games in alternatives to a murder mystery party.
- Hidden murderer: Some kits keep the murderer’s identity secret until the reveal, even from the player who is the murderer. The “How to Host a Murder” series is one example.
Check your kit first
Rules differ between games, and the host guide overrides general rules. If the kit’s rules conflict with the advice here, follow the kit.
Common misconceptions
- “There is one universal rulebook.” Each game sets its own.
- “Everyone can lie freely.” Many games limit lying, and some allow it only for the murderer.
- “The murderer always knows.” Some kits keep it secret until the end.
- “Only the detective can accuse.” Any guest can usually make an accusation.
For how the game looks from a player’s seat, see how to play and solve a murder mystery dinner game. For the basic format, see what a murder mystery dinner is. If you are writing your own game, can ChatGPT write a murder mystery game? covers how to keep the rules consistent.