Hosting

Murder Mystery Awards and Prize Ideas

Murder mystery awards ideas: categories like Best Detective and Best Costume, fair ways to score accusations, and budget prizes that keep the ending short.

On this page
  1. Core categories
  2. Fun extras
  3. Pick winners fairly
  4. Prize ideas on a budget
  5. Keep the awards short
  6. Hosting tips

Awards close the game and give guests a reason to laugh together after the reveal. They also reward more than the correct answer. A well-chosen set recognizes detective work, costume effort, and performance, so more guests leave feeling included.

Core categories

These five cover most games:

  • Best Detective: for the guest whose accusation is closest to the truth.
  • Best Costume: for the strongest outfit or the most on-theme look.
  • Best Performance: for the most committed acting, accents, or staying in character.
  • Most Suspicious: for the guest the others suspected most.
  • Best Liar: for the most convincing bluff. Use this only if the game allows lying.

Fun extras

Add one or two of these for variety:

  • Worst Detective, for the most creative wrong guess
  • Best Accent
  • Most Dramatic, for the most theatrical exit or death scene
  • Best Red Herring, for the clue that sent everyone the wrong way
  • Got Away With It, for the murderer who was never caught

Pick winners fairly

Judge costumes and performances by secret ballot. Each guest writes a vote on a slip, and the host counts the votes. Accusations are usually scored by the host.

  • Score each accusation in parts: the killer, the method, and the motive. For example, one point for each part.
  • Break ties with the most detailed reasoning, or with the first accusation submitted.
  • Set the rules before the game starts, and mention the awards in the briefing so guests know what is up for grabs.

The murderer can win too. A “Got Away With It” award, or a “best murderer” award, gives them credit for staying hidden.

Prize ideas on a budget

Most small prizes cost a few dollars, and a typical budget is roughly $1 to $10 per prize. Options include:

  • Dollar-store trophies, medals, or sashes
  • Printable certificates, which many commercial kits include (see what comes in a murder mystery party kit)
  • Chocolate or small candy, useful when several guests tie
  • Themed prizes, such as a magnifying glass, a mini bottle of wine, a mystery novel, or a detective badge

Small prizes for several guests tend to keep more people involved than one large prize.

Keep the awards short

Use three to six awards. Presenting them, along with the wrap-up, usually takes about ten to fifteen minutes. Hand them out after the reveal, not during the rounds, so the ending doesn’t slow the game.

Hosting tips

  • Hand out voting slips at the start, so they are ready for the costume and performance vote.
  • Keep dividable treats on hand in case of a tie.
  • Name the awards in the briefing, then present them after the reveal.

For the solving side of the night, see how to play and solve a murder mystery dinner game. Costume categories work best when guests know what to wear; do you dress up for a murder mystery dinner? covers that. For the full plan, see how to host a murder mystery dinner party.

The complete guide to hosting

How to Host a Murder Mystery Dinner Party at Home
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →