Hosting

What is a good gift for someone who loves murder mysteries?

A murder mystery party kit, a detective board game, or a classic crime novel makes a good gift. Here are picks for hosts, puzzle fans, readers, and viewers.

On this page
  1. For someone who likes to host
  2. For puzzle lovers
  3. Board games
  4. Books
  5. Watching
  6. Small detective-themed extras
  7. Subscription boxes
  8. Match the gift to the fan

A murder mystery party kit, a detective board game, or a classic crime novel makes a reliable gift. Choose by what the person enjoys: hosting a game, solving puzzles alone, reading, or watching. The ideas below cover each of those, so you can pick the one that fits.

For someone who likes to host

  • A murder mystery party kit, boxed or printable, so they can run their own game for friends.
  • Tickets to a dinner theatre murder mystery, as a night out. Check the date and what is included.

For puzzle lovers

  • Logic-grid mystery books, such as the “Murdle” series by G.T. Karber. These are puzzle books for solving alone. See the best murder mystery puzzle book for more.
  • Jigsaw puzzles that ask the solver to work out a crime from the picture.
  • Escape-room-in-a-box games, such as the EXIT: The Game series. Check the player count on the box before buying.
  • Cold-case puzzle files, where the solver reads case documents to find the answer. Several brands sell them.

Board games

  • Clue (Cluedo), first released in 1949
  • Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective, first released in 1981
  • Mysterium
  • Chronicles of Crime
  • Detective: A Modern Crime Board Game
  • Deception: Murder in Hong Kong

Many of these are group games. Check the player count before you buy, since some work better with a particular group size. Murder mystery board games like Clue compares player counts.

Books

Agatha Christie is one of the best-selling novelists of all time, and her books are a common first pick. Good starting points include “And Then There Were None,” “Murder on the Orient Express,” and “The Murder of Roger Ackroyd.”

Other crime writers include Arthur Conan Doyle, Dorothy L. Sayers, Richard Osman, Anthony Horowitz, and Tana French. For the genre’s origins, see what was the first ever murder mystery.

Watching

Popular picks include the Poirot series with David Suchet, Miss Marple, Columbo, and the Knives Out films. Box sets make a good gift for a fan who already has a favorite.

Small detective-themed extras

A magnifying glass, a deerstalker hat, a mug, or a bookmark is small, easy to wrap, and fun to use. These work well alongside a bigger gift.

Subscription boxes

Episodic case boxes, such as Hunt A Killer, send a new case on a schedule. Prices vary. Many subscriptions renew until they are cancelled, so check the renewal terms and the cancellation process before you buy.

Match the gift to the fan

Some fans love cozy whodunits. Others prefer true crime. A true crime book can miss the mark for a cozy fan, and the reverse is also true. If you’re not sure, pick something that works either way, such as a board game or a puzzle book, or ask a friend who knows the fan’s taste.

For a host gift, how to host a murder mystery dinner party gives the full picture of what a kit involves. For a dinner theatre gift, what a murder mystery dinner is explains what to expect at the show. For ready-made kits, see easy murder mystery party ideas.

The complete guide to hosting

How to Host a Murder Mystery Dinner Party at Home
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →