The short answer
Choose a printable kit if you have a large or unpredictable guest list, need a kit within a day or two, or want to reprint it for another group. Choose a boxed kit if you want to skip the printing, are buying a gift, or have a fixed group of about six to eight. Both formats cost roughly the same, and printing adds its own cost.
How the two formats differ
Printable and boxed kits differ in five ways:
- Delivery. Printable kits arrive as an instant PDF download. Boxed kits ship as physical components, which takes several days (varies).
- Group size. Printable kits are often scalable. Boxed kits usually have a fixed cast, commonly six to eight players.
- Prep. Printable kits need printing, cutting and sorting. Boxed kits are ready to play.
- Customization. Some printable kits include editable invitations or name tags. This varies by publisher.
- Reuse. Printable kits can usually be reprinted for a new group, subject to the license. Boxed kits depend on the condition of the components.
Printable kits: what to expect
Printable kits are instant. Once you pay, you can start printing. They are often scalable to larger groups, and some include editable invitations or name tags.
The trade-off is preparation. A printable kit can run to dozens of pages, and a large cast can need 50 to 100 pages or more (this varies). You will need paper, ink or toner, cardstock for name tags, envelopes for sorting clues, and scissors. Allow one to three hours for printing, cutting and sorting, and more for a large group. Printing one test copy first helps you catch layout problems early.
Boxed kits: what to expect
Boxed kits are ready to play. There is no printing step, which makes them a practical gift. For other ideas, see gifts for someone who loves murder mysteries. Shipping takes several days (this varies), so order well ahead of your party.
The limits are the fixed cast and the components. Extra characters are often not available. Some boxes include tear-open or write-on components, so those kits cannot be reused. Older boxed kits sometimes included audio CDs, while many modern kits use downloadable audio or video.
Boxed kits also rarely include props, costumes or decorations. Most are mainly paper materials, so plan for the rest. Murder mystery dinner props and decorations covers what to add.
Price: the two formats overlap
Both formats are commonly priced around $20 to $50, though this varies. Printable kits can look cheaper, but ink and cardstock add to the total, so the gap is smaller than it seems. Boxed kits can look more expensive, but they have no printing cost. Compare the full cost: shipping for a boxed kit, and printing supplies for a printable one.
Printable kits are not automatically lower quality. Many have more content than their boxed equivalents.
Which one should you choose?
Use this as a starting point:
- Choose printable if your guest list is large or uncertain, you need a kit quickly, or you want to reprint it for another group.
- Choose boxed if you want to skip printing, you are buying a gift, or your group is a fixed size of about six to eight.
- Choose either if the title comes in both formats. Some publishers sell both formats of the same game.
Before you order
Check the player count, the age rating and what the listing includes. For a checklist covering format, prep and content, read the murder mystery party kit guide. If you plan to print a free kit, free murder mystery party kits and scripts explains the license rules that apply. For what comes in a kit and what you still need to supply, see what comes in a murder mystery party kit. If you are hosting a large group, the 12-player guide covers printable and freeform options, and murder mystery parties for large groups sorts games by player count.