Props make a murder mystery feel real, but the game runs on the clues. Start with the essentials, then add decor that fits your theme and your budget. Most kits work with paper clues alone, so props are a bonus rather than a requirement. What comes in a murder mystery party kit lists what a kit usually covers.
Start with the essentials
These items support the game itself:
- Name tags with character names
- Clue envelopes labeled by round and character
- Notepads and pens for every guest
- Accusation cards
- A printed host guide, plus spare copies of every booklet
Print the essentials two or three days ahead, so you have time to fix any mistakes. The planning checklist shows when to print each item.
Detective props
Magnifying glasses, fingerprint cards, evidence bags, and case files add an investigator’s feel. Put them on a side table or in a box near the entrance, so guests can find them without asking.
Dress the crime scene
A few touches make the room look like the scene of a crime:
- Yellow crime scene tape across a doorway or the corner of a room
- A body outline on the floor in painter’s tape, which lifts off more cleanly than most tapes
- Numbered evidence markers on the tables
Check that tape and cords don’t create trip hazards, especially on busy floors.
Fake weapons and “poison”
Rubber knives, a toy candlestick, rope, and bottles labeled “poison” all work well. Use clearly labeled, harmless bottles, such as a bottle of juice with a skull label. Do not use real chemicals or medicine bottles as poison props.
Avoid realistic replica firearms. They can alarm neighbors or police, even at a party.
Lighting and sound
Dimmed lights, LED candles, string lights, and colored bulbs set the mood quickly. Use LED candles instead of open flames near costumes and paper clues.
A themed playlist helps. Thunder and rain sound effects can make a storm scene feel real. Keep the volume low enough that guests can still talk and read their clues.
Table and theme decor
Place cards with character names help guests find their seats and use each other’s names in character. Menus with themed dish names add to the atmosphere.
Decor depends on the era you have picked:
- 1920s: feathers, pearls, and gold accents (more in the Roaring 20s murder mystery dinner guide)
- Hollywood: a red carpet or a photo backdrop (see celebrity and Hollywood murder mystery party ideas)
- Wild West: hay bales and a lantern or two
A photo corner with a backdrop and a few themed props gives guests something to do between rounds.
Fake blood
A common home recipe is corn syrup tinted with red food coloring. A drop of blue or a little cocoa gives a darker shade.
Test the mix on a scrap of the fabric or surface you plan to use first. Food coloring stains fabric, grout, and wood, and it can be hard to remove. Keep fake blood off upholstery, carpet, and light fabrics.
Keep it safe
- Use LED candles, not open flames, near costumes and paper.
- Avoid realistic replica firearms.
- Do not use real chemicals or medicine bottles as poison props.
- Keep fake blood away from upholstery, carpet, and light-colored fabric.
- Keep walkways clear of cords, tape, and loose props.
Keep the budget in check
Dollar stores and printables cover most needs. Many decor sets come in under $50, though prices vary by region and retailer. Skip props the game doesn’t use. Too much decor can crowd the table and hide clue cards.
Print backups
Print a spare copy of every clue and booklet, and keep a host folder with the solution, spare packets, and the schedule. Keep the folder out of guests’ sight, since a visible solution can spoil the game. Common hosting mistakes covers that and other problems.
For the full hosting plan, see how to host a murder mystery dinner party. Food and table setup are covered in murder mystery menu ideas. For prize ideas to finish the night, see murder mystery awards ideas.