There is no single best murder mystery puzzle book. The right one depends on the kind of puzzle you enjoy. For logic-grid puzzles, try Murdle. For short cases with answers at the back, try the Sobol or Weber series. For the most demanding option, Cain’s Jawbone is the classic challenge. Check the current edition before you buy, since editions and prices change.
Logic puzzles: Murdle
- Murdle by G.T. Karber (2023) uses logic grids to solve murders. You work out the suspect, the weapon, the location and sometimes the motive.
- The detective is Deductive Logico, and the book grew out of Karber’s online daily puzzle.
- The puzzles get harder as the book goes on. Sequel volumes exist, so check the current list before buying.
- Each puzzle is self-contained logic, so you do not need outside knowledge.
Short cases: Two-Minute and Five-Minute Mysteries
- Donald J. Sobol’s Two-Minute Mysteries (1967) contains short cases you solve yourself.
- Ken Weber’s Five-Minute Mysteries series has short cases, with the solutions at the back.
- These suit casual solvers and quick breaks between games.
Extreme challenge: Cain’s Jawbone
Cain’s Jawbone, by “Torquemada” (Edward Powys Mathers), was first published in 1934. It is printed with its 100 pages out of order. Your task is to put the pages back in order and name six victims and their murderers. Many readers never finish it, so expect a serious commitment.
Crime-scene puzzles and casebook games
- Lawrence Treat’s Crime and Puzzlement (1981) has illustrated crime-scene puzzles.
- Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective (1981) is a boxed casebook game with a map and newspapers, rather than a book.
How to choose
- Logic fans: Murdle.
- Casual solvers: the short-case books.
- Extreme challenge: Cain’s Jawbone.
- Hosts looking for ideas: the crime-scene puzzles show how evidence can be laid out on a table.
Puzzle books and subscription boxes are different
A puzzle book is self-contained. A mystery subscription box, such as Hunt A Killer, releases physical props over time, so it is a different format.
Using puzzle books for your own party
A logic grid is a good model for a timeline. The timeline guide explains how to build one for your own game. Do not reuse a published puzzle at your party without permission. Write your own, using the clue ideas as a guide.