A red herring is a clue or a suspect that points away from the true solution. Used well, it keeps guests guessing and gives innocent characters something to do. Used badly, it makes the game unsolvable. Plan red herrings alongside the real clues, not after them.
What a red herring is
A red herring should be a true fact that misleads, not a false fact invented for the game. The phrase is often traced to William Cobbett’s 1807 account of using a smoked herring to lay a false trail, though the hunting story behind it is probably invented. For a party, the idea is what matters: the clue is real, but its meaning is misleading until the reveal.
Give each innocent suspect a suspicious clue
- A common rule of thumb is to give every innocent suspect at least one suspicious clue.
- Do not leave the murderer with zero suspicious clues. That makes them easy to spot.
- The murderer can also have a red herring that points at someone else, to frame them.
Make red herrings look like real clues
- Use the same card style and the same round timing as the real clues, so they do not stand out.
- Keep a clue ledger. Mark each clue as “true,” “red herring” or “eliminator,” and note the suspect it points to.
Tie them to real secrets
The best red herrings point to a real secret that is not murder: an affair, a theft, a debt or a false identity. Every red herring needs an innocent explanation, which you reveal by the end or at the reveal. Players feel cheated when a red herring is left unresolved.
Time them across the rounds
- Release the strongest red herring early, in round one.
- Hold the decisive real clue until the final round.
- Clear one red herring in the middle of the game to reward attentive players.
How many to use
Some hosts aim for roughly one red herring for every two or three real clues. Treat that as a starting point and tune it in playtesting. Too many make the game unsolvable and frustrating, while too few make it obvious.
Common mistakes
- Assuming more red herrings make a better mystery.
- Leaving a red herring unexplained when you reach the reveal. The solution and reveal guide explains how to cover each one.
- Thinking a red herring must be a person. It can be a weapon, a time or a location.
Test your ratio before the party. The playtest guide explains how to check whether testers are misled too much or too little. For the clues that point to the culprit, see clue ideas for a murder mystery.