Write the solution first. It sets the clues and the timeline, and every part of the reveal has to rest on it. A good solution names one culprit, shows their motive, means and opportunity, rules out each innocent suspect, and explains every red herring.
Write the solution before anything else
Start with the answer, then build the clues and the timeline from it. Working backward from the solution is the most reliable way to avoid clues that contradict each other. If you write the clues first, you will often find you have to rewrite them once you reach the solution.
Cover motive, means and opportunity
- Motive: why the culprit wanted the victim dead.
- Means: how they carried it out.
- Opportunity: how they were alone with the victim at the right time.
Only the culprit should have all three together. If an innocent suspect has all three, the solution is not clear enough.
Name the decisive clues
Name the two to five key clues that, combined, point only to the culprit. A solution is usually a chain of two or more clues rather than one decisive clue. The clue ideas guide lists the kinds of evidence that work well together.
Rule out each innocent suspect
- Show why each innocent suspect is ruled out, one by one, and cite the clue that does it.
- Explain every red herring with its innocent cause. The red herring guide covers how to set these up.
Collect accusations before the reveal
Before the reveal, have each guest write an accusation: the culprit, the motive, the method, and the clue that proved it. Award the best detective prize to the guest with the most correct accusations.
Reveal formats
- Host summary: the host or a detective reads a summary of the solution.
- Scripted confession: the murderer reads a scripted confession.
- Paragraph round: each player reads one paragraph of the solution.
Confessions add drama, but an evidence-led reveal works just as well.
Reveal structure and timing
- Keep the reveal to five to fifteen minutes. Long reveals lose the room.
- A simple order works well: recap the crime, eliminate the suspects, present the decisive clue, give the confession, then cover the loose ends.
- Seal the solution in an envelope, so the host can play too.
If a guest spots a plot hole
Acknowledge it. Do not improvise new evidence to cover the gap. Fix the problem in your notes before you run the game again.
A fair-play test
Ask whether a player could have reached the answer using only the clues they had. If the answer is no, a clue is missing or unclear. The playtest guide explains how to check this with testers before the party.
Common mistakes
- Adding new evidence at the reveal. Every fact in the solution must have been available to players. Knox’s 1929 rules expected all clues to be shown to the reader.
- Expecting total surprise. A good reveal makes guests think, “I should have seen that.”
- Assuming the murderer must confess. An evidence-led reveal is fine too.
For the wider process, see how to write your own murder mystery dinner party.