Most home murder mystery games are semi-scripted. Guests receive character booklets with a few read-aloud lines and improvise the rest. Write short lines, give each character something to reveal, hide and ask, and print them so they can be read in dim party lighting.
Semi-scripted is the usual format
Most home games use character booklets, with a few read-aloud lines plus improvisation. Word-for-word scripts suit rehearsed dinner theater, but they rarely work for a home party, where guests are eating and chatting.
Keep read-aloud lines short
- Keep scripted lines to one to three sentences. Guests read them cold, often while eating.
- Bold or highlight any line a guest must say aloud at a particular moment.
Use “if asked about X, say Y” prompts
Rather than writing full scenes, write short prompts. For example: “If asked where you were at nine, say you were in the library.” These let guests improvise without losing the clues, and they cover the questions you expect other guests to ask.
Give each character a goal each round
Give each character one thing to reveal, one thing to hide, and one person to question. Those three goals give every guest something to do in every round, which keeps idle players from getting bored.
Give each character a voice
- Pick a distinct vocabulary, a catchphrase, a verbal tic or period slang.
- Samples of 1920s slang include “the bee’s knees” (something excellent), “ossified” (drunk), “giggle water” (liquor) and “bluenose” (a prude).
- Western, Victorian and mob themes each benefit from three to five signature phrases per character.
- Period slang does not have to be accurate everywhere. A little flavor is enough.
Write subtext
Characters dodge, accuse and hint rather than stating facts outright. Dialogue should not carry the clues by itself. Physical clue cards are clearer, and guests are more likely to remember them.
Spread the back story
No single character should deliver the whole back story. Split the exposition across the cast, so that each guest hears only part of it and needs the others to fill in the rest.
Set the lying rule in writing
Write the lying rule into every booklet. A common one is that everyone except the murderer must tell the truth about the murder, but may keep secrets. Games vary, so state the rule plainly rather than assuming guests will know it.
Formatting for dim rooms
- Print the booklets large, at 12 to 14 point, for dim party lighting.
- Mark stage directions in brackets or italics, separate from the spoken lines.
The opening round
Open with introductions, plus one accusatory line per character to start the conversation. Give shy players plenty of written lines. Not every guest likes to improvise, and a booklet that gives them something to say can make the difference.
Common mistakes
- Using dialogue as the only way to deliver clues.
- Expecting every guest to improvise.
- Writing long speeches. Short lines are easier to read aloud and easier to follow.
For the roles these lines belong to, see murder mystery party character ideas. Test the lines before the party with the playtest guide.