A mafia murder mystery party works best when the family is the mystery: who inherits, who informs and who gets cut out of the take. The theme has strong touchstones in Prohibition-era Chicago and in 1940s and 1950s New York. It needs some care, though, so the humor lands on the characters and not on real people or groups.
Choose a setting
These settings suit the theme:
- Prohibition-era Chicago
- A 1940s or 1950s New York family dinner
- A Godfather-style wedding
- A nightclub
- The back room of an Italian restaurant
Real history as background
Al Capone ran the Chicago Outfit and was convicted of tax evasion in 1931. A tax conviction makes a useful plot twist, such as a clue hidden in the ledgers.
The St. Valentine’s Day Massacre, on February 14, 1929 in Chicago, killed seven men. Use real events like this as background only. Don’t stage them, and keep the victims fictional.
Ranks and roles
The traditional ranks are boss (don), underboss, consigliere, caporegime (capo), soldiers and associates. Roles that fit a dinner game include a don, a widow, an underboss, a consigliere, a nightclub owner, a lounge singer, a bookie, a rival boss, a crooked cop and an FBI agent.
Motives
- Succession after the don steps aside
- An informant in the family
- A skimmed take from a business
- A broken alliance between two families
The code of silence
Omertà is the Mafia’s code of silence. It’s a good mechanic: a character can refuse to answer a question, which pushes guests to find clues another way. Use it sparingly, or the game can stall.
Blending in Mafia-style rules
Some hosts blend classic Mafia party rules into a murder mystery. If you do, consider secret objectives or a hidden informant rather than full night-time eliminations. That keeps more guests involved until the end.
Dress code
Pinstripe or double-breasted suits, fedoras, spats and suspenders suit the men. For the women, cocktail dresses, faux furs and pearls work well.
Pinstripes are more of a Hollywood convention than a strict 1920s fact, but they read clearly as gangster costume.
Food
The menu can include antipasto, spaghetti and meatballs, lasagna, garlic bread, cannoli, tiramisu and espresso.
Spaghetti and meatballs is Italian-American rather than traditional Italian, so call the menu Italian-American or simply a family-style dinner. Keep the humor aimed at the gangsters, and avoid broad jokes about Italian people.
Drinks and décor
Serve Chianti or a Negroni for the adults, and offer a non-alcoholic option, such as a sparkling soda with a lemon twist. A Godfather cocktail (Scotch and amaretto) is a fun signature drink for those who drink.
For décor, use red-checked tablecloths, a family portrait and candles in Chianti bottles. Use LED candles in the bottles rather than open flames.
Phrases to pick up
Guests can use phrases such as “sleeps with the fishes,” but it comes from The Godfather rather than documented mafia slang. Mentioning that origin can be a fun aside for the host.
Safety
Use obviously fake prop guns, especially if guests travel to the party in costume.
For more ideas, see the murder mystery dinner party theme ideas guide. For a 1920s alternative with Prohibition plots, see the roaring 20s guide.