A medieval murder mystery dinner party brings a castle to the table: royal banquets, tournaments, poisoned cups and a disputed crown. The Middle Ages ran roughly from 500 to 1500 CE, and exact dates vary by source. A castle banquet or a late-medieval court makes a flexible setting, because it allows for a wide range of costumes and menus.
Choose a setting
Settings include a royal banquet, a coronation feast, a tournament or joust, a wedding feast, and a monastery. A royal banquet gives you the most cast roles. A monastery gives a quieter, more secretive tone.
The cast
Useful roles include a king, a queen, a prince or princess, a knight, a jester, a court physician, an alchemist, an abbess or monk, a minstrel, a lady-in-waiting, an executioner and a blacksmith. Give the physician and the alchemist a clear role in the story if you include a poison plot.
Plot hooks
- A poisoned royal cup
- A disputed succession
- A betrayed knight
- A forbidden romance
Poison in the story only
Period poisons include belladonna (deadly nightshade), hemlock, wolfsbane (aconite), foxglove and arsenic. Several of these are dangerous. Keep the poison in the story: a clue such as a physician’s ledger or an empty jar labeled “tonic” can carry the plot without anything toxic on the table. Never serve a real plant or substance as part of the game.
Dining the medieval way
Diners of the period ate with knives, spoons and fingers. Forks spread across most of Europe only after the medieval period. For a modern party, provide forks and napkins, and use thick slices of bread on boards as a nod to trenchers, the thick slices of stale bread once used as plates.
Menu
Period-plausible food includes roast chicken, pork or beef, pottage, bread, cheese, root vegetables, pies and honey cakes.
Leave out ingredients that reached Europe later. Turkey, potatoes, tomatoes and corn came from the Americas, so they don’t fit a medieval European table.
Drinks
Mead (honey wine), ale and spiced wine (hippocras) are period drinks. For a non-alcoholic option, serve cider or juice in goblets.
Costumes
Useful pieces include tunics, surcoats, cloaks, belts with pouches, and circlets or crowns. The tall cone-shaped hennin dates from the 15th century, so save it for a late-medieval court.
Décor
Banners, heraldic shields, tapestries, goblets, long communal tables and LED candles set the scene. Use LED candles rather than open flames, especially near fabric.
Clues
Sealed letters with wax seals (sticker seals work well at a modern party), an apothecary’s ledger, and a coat of arms with a missing quarter all make good clues.
Myths to skip
- Horned helmets are a 19th-century invention, even for Vikings, and don’t belong to castle knights.
- Educated medieval people didn’t think the Earth was flat.
- Chastity belts are largely a later myth.
Safety
Use foam or plastic prop swords, never real blades. Keep the poison in the story, and serve only food and drink you have prepared yourself.
For the full set of theme options, see the murder mystery dinner party theme ideas guide.