A 1950s murder mystery dinner party suits a dinner game well. The decade has a clear look, a strong soundtrack and a built-in sense of suspicion. The Cold War and the Red Scare give you a natural secret, and a diner gives you a stage where every character can cross paths.
How the night runs
In a murder mystery dinner, each guest gets a character with a secret. Guests mingle and trade clues over the first courses, then vote on who they think did it. For a 1950s game, run a round of clues with each course, hold the final accusation before dessert, and reveal the solution at the end. For the general steps, see the murder mystery dinner party theme ideas guide.
Pick a setting
These settings fit the decade:
- A diner with a counter and a jukebox
- A sock hop at a high school gym
- A drive-in theater
- A suburban dinner party with a neighborhood secret
- A Cold War spy ring
- A Hollywood noir set, dark and moody
Pick one main setting and let the others appear as side stories. For a 1950s-themed birthday, see our guide to murder mystery birthday themes.
Characters
Useful characters include a diner owner, a soda jerk, a waitress, a greaser, a cheerleader, a jock, a traveling salesman, a housewife, a crooner and an FBI agent. The greaser, the crooner and the FBI agent give you strong suspects.
Secrets and clues that fit the decade
- The Red Scare: Senator Joseph McCarthy’s hearings ran roughly from 1950 to 1954, so a “suspected spy” is a good secret.
- A jukebox request that points to a particular guest.
- A drive-in ticket stub with the wrong date on it.
- A love letter tucked inside a letterman jacket.
Costumes
For women, the look includes poodle skirts, swing dresses, cardigans, saddle shoes, ponytails tied with scarves and cat-eye glasses. Poodle skirts were a teen fad in the early and mid-1950s, not what everyone wore, so they suit a younger character best.
For men, the greaser look is a leather jacket, a white T-shirt, rolled jeans and a pompadour. Letterman jackets and skinny ties are good alternatives.
If a full outfit is too much, ask each guest for one signature piece, such as a scarf, a cardigan or a letterman jacket.
Music and décor
Rock and roll took off in the mid-1950s. Elvis Presley’s “Heartbreak Hotel” came out in 1956, which makes a good opening song. Keep the playlist to the mid-1950s so the night stays in one decade.
For décor, use black-and-white checkerboard tablecloths, red vinyl cushions, chrome details and vinyl records as placemats or centerpieces.
Menu
Period food includes tuna casserole, meatloaf, Jell-O molds, deviled eggs, pigs in a blanket, burgers, milkshakes and root beer floats. Swanson launched its TV dinners in 1953, so serving one course on compartmented trays is a nod to the era.
Period cocktails include the martini, the Manhattan, the Tom Collins, the Grasshopper and the highball. For a non-alcoholic choice, a milkshake or a root beer float fits the diner setting well.
A suspenseful tone
Hitchcock films of the era set a useful tone for the game. Rear Window (1954) and Dial M for Murder (1954) both build suspense in a single location, which suits a dinner party. For a courtroom twist, Witness for the Prosecution (1957) is another good reference.
Keep the decades separate
Several popular films and shows are often mixed in with the 1950s but belong to later decades:
- Grease (1978) and Happy Days (1974) are 1970s nostalgia, although Grease is set in 1958 to 1959.
- Fondue parties are more of a 1960s and 1970s thing than a 1950s one.
- The Rat Pack’s Las Vegas look fits only the late 1950s and the 1960s, so use it sparingly.
If your guests enjoy the decade’s pop culture, the 80s murder mystery party guide covers a different era with its own costumes and clues.
Safety
Keep candles away from full skirts and loose scarves. If you include toy weapons, make sure they look obviously fake.