A pirate murder mystery party gives you a ship, a crew and a treasure map. The crew’s shares of the loot are an easy source of motive. The Golden Age of Piracy is usually dated to about 1650 to 1730, with its peak around 1716 to 1726, so an early-1700s setting is a sound starting point. Much of what people picture as pirate lore comes from later fiction, which is worth knowing when you choose costumes and clues.
Choose a plot
These plot ideas work well for a dinner game:
- A treasure map that only some guests can read
- A dispute over shares of the loot
- A planned mutiny
- A hidden navy spy among the crew
- A betrayal over a marooning
The shares are a motive
Pirate crews often agreed to written articles that set out how the loot would be divided. A captain often received one and a half to two shares. Marooning, leaving a crew member on an island, was a real punishment named in some of these articles.
A dispute over those shares gives every guest a reason to want the captain’s place, which makes it a strong engine for suspicion.
Cast
Useful roles include a captain, a quartermaster, a first mate, a navigator, a ship’s surgeon, a cook, a powder monkey, a governor’s daughter, a navy officer and a privateer.
Real pirates make good inspiration for fictional characters. Blackbeard (Edward Teach) was killed in 1718, and Anne Bonny and Mary Read were tried in Jamaica in 1720. Use their stories as inspiration rather than as real people in the plot.
Costumes
Keep it simple: a bandana, a loose shirt, a waistcoat, boots and a hat. Guests who want more can add a sash or a belt with a pouch. For safety, use plastic hooks rather than metal ones.
Décor
Fishing nets, rope, barrels, lanterns, a treasure chest and Jolly Roger flags set the scene. Not all pirate flags showed a skull and crossbones, so you can vary the designs.
Food and drink
Shipboard food was basic, with hardtack, salt pork, fish and citrus. For a party, serve fish, tropical fruit, “gold coin” chocolates and a rum punch. A non-alcoholic punch works just as well for guests who don’t drink.
Grog, rum diluted with water, is traditionally credited to Admiral Vernon in 1740. A punch with plenty of water is a playful nod to it.
Clues
- Torn pieces of a treasure map that have to be matched
- A page from the ship’s log with a missing line
- A black spot card, a device borrowed from Treasure Island
- A captain’s ledger with an entry that doesn’t add up
Myths to skip
- Walking the plank is mostly a myth, with very few documented cases.
- Pirate parrots and treasure maps come mostly from Treasure Island (1883).
- The “arr” accent was popularized by Robert Newton in the 1950 film of Treasure Island.
- Not every pirate flag showed a skull and crossbones.
Safety
Use plastic swords and hooks, and keep lanterns battery-powered. Guests who sail into the room in costume can trip over a rope or a barrel, so keep walkways clear.
For the full set of theme options, see the murder mystery dinner party theme ideas guide. For a medieval alternative with its own castle cast, see the medieval guide.