Writing Your Own

How to Playtest Your Murder Mystery Before the Party

How to playtest your murder mystery before the party in four steps: a logic check, a cold solve, a table read and a timed run, plus what to ask your testers.

On this page
  1. Who to test with
  2. Step 1: logic check
  3. Step 2: cold solve
  4. Step 3: table read
  5. Step 4: timed run
  6. What to ask testers
  7. Tune the difficulty
  8. Final checks
  9. Common mistakes

Playtest your murder mystery with two to four people who will not attend the real party. Test the logic, then the solve, then the reading, then the timing. A playtest shows whether guests can solve the game, how long each round takes, and whether the lines make sense when read aloud.

Who to test with

  • Use two to four people who will not attend the real party, so they do not already know the answer.
  • If you cannot find them, swap mysteries with another host and test each other’s games.
  • Reading the game yourself does not count. You already know the answer, so you cannot judge how hard it is.

Step 1: logic check

  • Confirm that the solution follows from the given clues alone.
  • Check the timeline for impossible overlaps before any testers see the game. The timeline guide explains what to look for.

Step 2: cold solve

Give a tester all the clues and the timeline, without the solution. See whether they reach it, and ask them why they guessed it. A correct guess for the wrong reason is a sign that a clue is missing or unclear.

Step 3: table read

Have testers read the character booklets aloud. This catches confusing lines, wrong information and lines that are too long to say comfortably. The dialogue guide has tips for keeping lines readable.

Step 4: timed run

  • Time each round against your target, which is often 20 to 40 minutes per round.
  • Check that each character has something to do in every round. Idle players get bored.

What to ask testers

  • When did they first suspect the culprit?
  • Which clue convinced them?
  • Which parts were confusing?

Tune the difficulty

  • Aim for some, but not all, players to solve the game. This is a rule of thumb, so tune it to your group.
  • If testers solve it in the first round, move a key clue later or add a red herring.
  • If nobody solves it, add an eliminating clue or make the decisive clue clearer.

Final checks

  • Check that every red herring has an explanation in the solution.
  • Proofread names, times and places across all the materials. One mismatch can break the logic.
  • Print-test the cards and booklets, checking the font size, the cutting lines and the envelope labels.
  • Do the final test at least a few days before the party, so there is time to fix anything that turns up.
  • Retest after any major change. One test is not enough.

Common mistakes

  • Treating testers’ guesses as proof. Ask why they guessed.
  • Testing with guests who will attend the real party. They may spoil the game.

For the wider process, see how to write your own murder mystery dinner party.

The complete guide to writing your own

How to Write Your Own Murder Mystery Dinner Party
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →