Four players is below the size most boxed murder mystery games are built for, which is usually six to eight. That doesn’t rule out a murder mystery for four. It means picking a game written for a small cast, and avoiding the common mistake of cutting down a bigger game. This guide covers role-play games for four, cooperative case files and what to plan for a small table.
Four is below most boxed games
Most boxed scripted games cast six to eight players, so look for titles written for four, or for four to six. Check the listed range before you buy. A game written for four is not the same as a six-player game with two roles removed.
Role-play games written for four
In a four-player role-play game, the victim is usually a non-player, which leaves four suspects. Each player holds more clues and dialogue than they would in a larger game, so a good four-player game gives every suspect a clear motive and a few red herrings.
The host can usually play too. Games for four often keep the solution in a sealed envelope, so the host can take a role without knowing the answer.
Cooperative case files for four
Cooperative case files are a different kind of game. Nobody plays a suspect. The players work together to solve a case using documents, evidence and timelines. Several case-file games suit a table of four, including:
- Hunt A Killer, which works with one or more players
- University Games’ Murder Mystery Party Case Files, which work with one or more players
- Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective, which plays one to eight players
Detective: A Modern Crime Board Game (one to five players) and Chronicles of Crime (one to four players) also fit a small table. For more case-file options, including ones for two, see murder mystery games for two.
Player counts vary by edition, so check the box before you buy.
Board and escape-room options
Clue (Cluedo) plays two to six players in recent editions and three to six in older ones. Escape-room boxes such as Exit (one to four players) and Unlock! (one to six players) suit a table of four. They overlap with murder mysteries, but they are puzzle games rather than murder role-play.
Why cutting a bigger game rarely works
It’s tempting to remove two characters from a six-player game and call it a four-player game. Clues in a murder mystery are tied to specific roles, though. When you remove characters, the solution can break, or clues end up with no one to read them. Choose a game built for four instead.
Planning a four-player evening
- A four-player game typically runs 1.5 to 2.5 hours.
- Most have two or three rounds, then an accusation and the reveal.
- A small table means dinner and play can happen together.
- A small game isn’t necessarily quicker to prepare. Each guest needs more reading.
For a larger table, see murder mystery games for 5, 6 or 7 players. For a general guide to how many people a game can take, see how many people you can have at a murder mystery party.