Five, six or seven guests is a comfortable size for a murder mystery. Many published games are written for 6 to 8 players, so six and seven are well served. Five is a little below many games’ minimums, but it works with the right game, or with a host who takes a role. This guide covers how to match a game to a small cast, what to do with optional roles, and where free games fit in.
Why 5, 6 and 7 need different planning
Each size has its own trade-offs:
- Six is a common sweet spot for published games.
- Seven fits the 6 to 8 range that many games list.
- Five is below many games’ minimums. Look for titles that list 4 to 6 or 5 to 8 players.
With a small cast, every player holds more clues and speaks more. Choose outgoing guests for the key roles, and expect each guest to need a bit more reading time.
Finding a game with the right player range
Check the range on the box or product page, not just the headline number. A game that says “6 to 8” usually marks one or two characters as optional. With six players, you drop both optional roles. With eight, you keep them all.
Don’t cut random characters from a bigger game to make it fit. Only the roles the designer marked as optional can be removed, because the solution often depends on the others.
The victim is often already dead or played by a non-guest, so the victim may not count toward your total. Check the host guide before you count heads.
Hosting five guests
Five is below the minimum of many published games, so look for a game with a 4 to 6 or 5 to 8 range. In a group this small, the host can often take a role too. Pick a role that doesn’t need the solution, and only do this if the game’s host guide keeps the solution sealed until the reveal.
Printable and downloadable games for five exist, but they differ in length and setup. Read the full listing before you buy.
Hosting six guests
Six is the comfortable middle. Most 6 to 8 games work well with six once you’ve dropped the optional roles. Six people fit around a 6-foot rectangular table or a 60-inch round table without crowding.
Hosting seven guests
Seven fits the 6 to 8 range of many games, so you can often run a game as written and fill every role. A game written for eight works with seven only if it names an optional role you can drop.
Seating is the main practical issue. On a 6-foot rectangular table, seven people need an end seat, so plan the layout before the night. If the cast is an odd number, our guide to odd numbers of guests covers casting tricks that work for small groups too.
Free murder mystery games for six
Free printable and downloadable games for six exist from various publishers and hobby sites. Quality and completeness vary a lot, so check before you print. Look for:
- A full solution, kept sealed for the host
- Clue cards or evidence for each round
- A character sheet for each role, with motives and relationships
- Clear instructions on the number of rounds and how long each one runs
A free script that is missing the solution or the clue cards is not a complete game, however good the premise looks.
What it costs
Prices vary widely. Free printables cost nothing. Paid downloads and boxed kits cost more, and boxes usually cost the most. Digital downloads are often the cheapest paid option, but prices depend on the title and on whether you buy a PDF or a physical box. Check the current price on the seller’s page before you plan your budget.
Planning the evening
A small-group evening usually runs 2 to 3 hours with dinner. A few planning steps help:
- Plan around three rounds of clues, matched to the starter, main course and dessert.
- Send character booklets or descriptions 1 to 2 weeks ahead so guests can plan costumes.
- Ask about food allergies when you invite guests, especially if courses are tied to rounds.
For a guest count closer to four, see murder mystery games for 4 players. For eight, see murder mystery dinner games for 8 players.