Eight is the classic size for a murder mystery dinner. Many boxed and downloadable games are written for exactly eight, and it’s a comfortable number for one table, one set of courses and one host. This guide covers how to find eight-player games, cast them, match rounds to a meal, and handle a guest who drops out or an extra guest who turns up.
Why eight is the classic size
The classic How to Host a Murder sets were built around eight guests, traditionally with four male and four female roles. University Games’ Murder Mystery Party boxes are mostly built for about eight players, but check each box, since counts vary.
Finding games written for eight
Check the exact player count on the box or listing. Some games list a range, such as 8 to 10 or 6 to 8, so an eight-player listing doesn’t always mean the game was written for exactly eight.
Downloadable games for eight also exist. Quality varies, so confirm that each download includes a full solution and all the character materials before you print it.
Check the character list for gender, too. Older eight-player games often have fixed-gender roles, while newer ones are more often flexible, though not all of them are.
Casting eight
In a fixed-cast game, every character carries clues, so all eight guests need to attend. Send character information 1 to 2 weeks ahead so guests can plan costumes and read their roles.
Gender-flexible characters make casting easier when the guest list isn’t four men and four women. If the characters are fixed, check the guest list before you send invitations.
Seating eight
A 60-inch round table or a 6- to 8-foot rectangular table seats eight. Keep the table clear enough that guests can read their character booklets and see the host when the reveal starts.
Matching rounds to courses
Many eight-player games run three rounds of clues, followed by accusations and a reveal. Rounds that match the courses work well: an appetizer round, a main-course round and a dessert round, with the reveal over dessert or coffee.
A dinner for eight usually runs 2.5 to 3 hours. Budget roughly 30 to 60 minutes per round, depending on the menu.
When someone drops out or joins
Plan for a no-show before the night, not on the day.
- If the missing character is optional, cut that role. Only roles the game marks as optional can be removed.
- If the missing character is essential, the host reads that character’s clues aloud, or a backup guest takes the role.
An eight-player game won’t work with seven unless it names an optional role you can drop. For an extra guest, see games for an odd number of guests, which covers how to fill an extra seat without turning anyone away.
The host’s role
The host can usually play at eight. Many games include a host guide that keeps the solution sealed until the end, so the host can take a character without knowing the answer in advance.
The host doesn’t have to cook everything, either. A potluck or takeout fits between rounds, and the host can focus on running the game.
Free and casual options
Free printable murder mystery games for eight exist. As with any free script, check that the solution and clue cards are complete before you print. Free games vary in quality, so one complete download is worth more than several incomplete ones.
For a bigger cast, see dinner games for 10 players. For six or seven, see games for 5, 6 or 7 players.
Mistakes to avoid
- Assuming an older game suits every guest list. Check fixed-gender roles before you invite anyone.
- Expecting an eight-player game to work with seven unless it names an optional role.
- Expecting the host to cook. A potluck or takeout works between rounds.