Fifteen or sixteen guests is where a murder mystery starts to need a different plan. Most boxed scripted games cast six to eight players, so at this size you’ll usually need a freeform game, a base game with expansions, or a team format. This guide covers how to choose a game, handle roles and no-shows, set up the room, and run the evening with a host and a co-host.
Two 8-player games are not one 16-player game
It can be tempting to run two copies of an eight-player game at two tables. The tables never interact, though. You end up with two separate parties and two separate reveals, not one shared mystery. If you want everyone in one story, choose a game built for the full group.
Choosing a game for 15 or 16
Look for games that list a range including your count, such as 12 to 20 or 10 to 30. Freeform games are usually the most flexible at this size, and some base games sell expansions that add roles.
Before you buy, check:
- The total number of characters, since a 12-character game can’t simply seat 16
- How many roles are optional
- Whether the game includes a host guide and detective or investigator roles
Essential roles, spares and no-shows
Mark each role as essential or optional. Fill the essential roles first, starting with the murderer and key witnesses, and then fill the optional ones. Pre-assign characters and send packets ahead of time. Assigning characters at the door is risky at this size, because guests need time to prepare.
Keep spare packets for one or two optional roles, in case someone arrives late or drops out. Not every guest needs a suspect role either. Witnesses, investigators and bystanders are normal, so 16 guests don’t have to mean 16 suspects.
Seating and space
Plan about 12 to 15 square feet per seated guest. That works out to roughly 180 to 240 square feet for dinner for 15 or 16 people. Two 72-inch round tables, which seat 10 each, or two 8-foot rectangular tables, which seat 8 to 10 each, both work well.
Freeform play can also work standing up or spread across several tables. Keep a clear spot for group announcements, and leave room for small huddles. Sixteen people talking at once gets loud quickly.
Running the evening
A 15 or 16 player evening typically runs 3 to 4 hours. Most follow this order:
- A mingling intro
- Three or four rounds of clues
- Written accusations
- The reveal
At this size the host should stop playing a suspect. The host runs the clues, the timing and the reveal. A co-host handles food and drinks, so the host can focus on the rounds.
Collect accusations on written sheets. Verbal accusations from 16 people take too long, and written sheets give you a record to check at the reveal.
Dress code and invitations
Most murder mystery dinners suggest a dress code on the invitation, usually tied to the game’s theme, such as a decade or a setting. Say whether costumes are expected or optional. Guests who know what to expect plan better, and the character packet can say what costume, if any, each role needs.
Food between rounds
Buffet or family-style service between rounds usually works better than plated courses at this size. A set of dishes on each table, or a food station, lets guests eat without waiting for a course to match a round.
Safety
- Collect food allergies with the RSVP.
- Keep candles away from costumes in crowded rooms.
- Check venue occupancy limits if you’re renting space.
- Keep prop weapons obviously fake.
For slightly smaller groups, see dinner games for 10 players. For 20 or more, see murder mystery parties for 20 people. For the general question of how many guests a game can take, see how many people you can have at a murder mystery party.