Games by Group Size

Murder Mystery Games When You Have an Odd Number of Guests

Odd number of guests? Odd numbers only cause trouble with fixed-cast games. Learn how to cast an extra guest, use optional roles well and plan for no-shows.

On this page
  1. Odd numbers matter only for fixed-cast games
  2. Buy for a range, not an exact count
  3. Optional roles, and what you can’t cut
  4. Filling an extra seat
  5. Spares and late arrivals
  6. No-show plan
  7. What doesn’t work

An odd number of guests is only a problem for some games. It matters for fixed-cast games, where every character needs a player. Freeform and team games absorb an extra guest without much trouble. This guide covers how to choose a game for an uneven group, which roles you can cut and which you can’t, and how to fill an extra seat.

Odd numbers matter only for fixed-cast games

In a fixed-cast game, each character has its own clues, so the cast has to match your guest list. Freeform and team games are more flexible, since a guest can take an extra character or a detective role. Check the cast before you decide whether an odd count is a problem.

Buy for a range, not an exact count

A game that lists a range, such as six to nine or eight to twelve, gives you room to adjust. A game that lists one exact number leaves you no flexibility. Choose a range that covers your count.

Optional roles, and what you can’t cut

Many games mark one to four roles as optional, and you can cut those to reach your count. Two rules hold in every case:

  • Never cut the murderer. The solution depends on them.
  • Never cut a character whose clues the solution depends on. Check the host guide to see which roles are safe to remove.

Filling an extra seat

If you have one guest too many or one too few, these options usually work:

  • The host plays a role. Pick one that doesn’t need the solution, and check the host guide first.
  • A guest plays the victim. The victim can “die” early and then help run the game, or play a ghost.
  • Two guests share a character. Twins, business partners or a married couple can share one role.
  • Add a witness or reporter. A simple extra role can receive copies of public clues, so the guest is part of the story.

Gender-flexible characters also help when the guest list doesn’t split evenly by gender.

Spares and late arrivals

Have one or two spare packets ready for late arrivals. Spares let you bring someone in without rewriting the cast on the spot.

No-show plan

If a guest doesn’t come, the host reads the missing role’s clues aloud, or passes them to another player. Plan this before the night, not on the day.

What doesn’t work

  • Turning a guest away. An odd number doesn’t require it.
  • Letting an extra guest just watch. Give them a role or a job.
  • Assuming a couple has to play a couple. Couples can take separate roles.

For the cast sizes around this one, see murder mystery dinner games for 8 players, games for 5, 6 or 7 players and dinner games for 10 players.

The complete guide to games by group size

Murder Mystery Parties for Large Groups: Games by Player Count
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →